Five Points Athens trendy neighborhood shops and cafes

Five Points Homes for Sale

Own a piece of Athens' most vibrant neighborhood. Historic 1920s homes at the intersection of Milledge & Lumpkin, where walkable culture meets timeless character.

Athens' Cultural Heart

Located at the iconic intersection of South Milledge Avenue and South Lumpkin Street, Five Points represents the soul of Athens. This historic 1920s neighborhood is your gateway to experiencing authentic Athens culture, with everything walkable from your front door.

From Independent Baking Co. and Avid Bookshop to upscale dining at Five & Ten and Donna Chang's, you'll own a home in the epicenter of Athens' most diverse and vibrant community. Live where character meets convenience.

Five Points Athens unique local shops and cafes

Historic Home Styles for Sale

Authentic 1920s architecture with modern investment potential

Historic Cottages

Authentic 1920s-1940s cottages featuring original hardwood floors, built-in bookshelves, and period architectural details that modern construction can't replicate.

  • 800-1,300 sq ft
  • $300K-$500K range
  • Original character
  • Private yards
  • Prime walkable location

Updated Homes

Historic homes with thoughtful modern renovations, combining Five Points character with contemporary comfort and efficiency.

  • 1,200-1,800 sq ft
  • $450K-$650K range
  • Modern systems
  • Updated kitchens
  • Historic charm preserved

Investment Properties

Multi-unit properties perfect for owner-occupants or investors seeking rental income in Athens' most desirable walkable neighborhood.

  • 1,000-2,500 sq ft
  • $400K-$750K range
  • Rental income potential
  • Separate entrances
  • Strong appreciation

Qualifying Five Points Property

Property within 2 miles of Five Points intersection that meets all criteria

Property at 570 Prince Avenue
Residential
$5,120,000 $471.80/sq ft

570 Prince Avenue

Athens, GA 30601

5 bed
6.5 bath
10,852 sq ft

Welcome to 570 Prince Avenue, notably known as the University of Georgia’s President's House and an important part of Athens’ history. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places, this distinguished landmark is being offered for sale for the first time. Meticulously maintained and updated, while keeping its timeless historic charm, this iconic home is nestled on approximately five acres along the tree-lined streets near downtown Athens. Over the decades, thousands of people have attended events here, and until recently, it has always been home to the University’s President. Constructed in the 1850’s, this home has so much architectural significance, showcasing period elements and meticulous craftsmanship, and many of the original details inside and outside of the home remain. From the famous gardens to the expansive wraparound porch, every corner of 570 Prince Avenue whispers stories of generations past, inviting new owners to become part of its enduring legacy. Inquire to learn more about the protective easement and zoning.

Built in 1857
View Details
Listing #CM1019245
Property at 255 Plum Nelly Road
Residential
$3,395,000 $669.76/sq ft

255 Plum Nelly Road

Athens, GA 30606

3 bed
4.0 bath
5,069 sq ft

Set on 5.58 acres along the Oconee River, this award-winning Chatts Island estate blends historic character with refined modern luxury. Originally built in the 1940s and thoughtfully renovated, the home offers over 5,000 SF of elegant living with four fireplaces, rich hardwoods, a grand curved staircase, and multiple French doors opening to sweeping outdoor spaces. The grounds feature manicured gardens, a terraced lawn, saltwater pool, covered slate patio, grilling kitchen, screened garden house, and a pickleball court. Inside, enjoy a chef’s kitchen with pro-grade range, with dual ovens, wet bar service area with heart pine walls, and charming breakfast nook. The owner’s suite offers a fireplace, custom closets, and spa bath. Additional guest suites are located on the upper level, a flexible library/4th bedroom option, and a vaulted bonus room above the garage offer exceptional versatility. A rare riverfront estate and 2025 Piedmont Garden Tour participant! ASK FOR PROPERTY WEBSITE!

Built in 1941
View Details
Listing #CL343898
Property at 201 Westminster
Residential
$3,200,000 $381.13/sq ft

201 Westminster

Athens, GA 30607

5 bed
8,396 sq ft

Welcome to your dream home in the exclusive gated horse community of Saddle Shoals. This custom-built brick home is an exquisite, private retreat set on four pristine acres. As you enter the home, you will be greeted by the grandeur of the main level incorporating fine craftsmanship, meticulously curated design elements, like rich, hardwood floors and intricate moldings that produce a classic, enduring style throughout. This home features five spacious bedrooms, including a luxurious primary suite and a secondary bedroom on the main level. The floor plan seamlessly connects the keeping room, breakfast area, family room, and stunning kitchen. With custom cabinets, a large center island, walk-in pantry, and a suite of premium appliances, the kitchen is truly the center of this amazing home. Step out onto the covered porch and take in the beautiful views of your own private pool and endless outdoor entertaining spaces. The primary suite is a true sanctuary, boasting a lavish bathroom with a large walk-in closet and breathtaking tilework. Upstairs, you'll find two additional, spacious bedrooms and bathrooms plus a grand bonus space that could also serve as a third bedroom. There is ample storage space throughout the home as well as an elevator for ease. The finished basement is a home unto itself, featuring a great room with a fireplace, a recreational room with a second fireplace, media room, poker room, and a guest suite with full bath. There is an attached, three-car garage and an additional, detached three-car garage featuring a finished 1200 square foot guest house above. This area includes two bedrooms, two and a half bathrooms, a family room, full kitchen, dining, and stunning views of the four acre property. Saddle Shoals offers private gated entrances, a riding rink, horse trails, and man other amenities, making it the perfect setting for equestrian enthusiasts. Don't miss this amazing opportunity to own a custom home in beautiful horse country, just minutes from Athens, Georgia.

Built in 2025
View Details
Listing #CL335820
Property at 1180 Allgood Road
Residential
$2,995,000 $337.58/sq ft

1180 Allgood Road

Athens, GA 30606

6 bed
6.0 bath
8,872 sq ft

Set on eight private acres in Oconee County with an Athens address, this Georgian-inspired estate combines timeless architecture with sophisticated design. The main level features a formal dining room, a stunning kitchen with quartzite counters, custom cabinetry, wine tower, pecky cypress beams, and a hidden walk-in pantry. The adjoining living area and screened porch overlook manicured grounds and a resort-style pool with spa. The primary suite and an additional guest suite are located on the main level. Upstairs includes a media room, two bedrooms joined by a Jack-and-Jill bath, and a third guest suite. The terrace level offers a full living area, bedroom, bath, and direct access to the pool and full pool bath. Additional highlights include an indoor basketball court, three-car garage, and inviting front porch surrounded by mature trees and natural privacy.

Built in 2022
View Details
Listing #CL341871
Property at 577 Cloverhurst Avenue
Residential
$2,749,000 $465.54/sq ft

577 Cloverhurst Avenue

Athens, GA 30606

5 bed
5.5 bath
5,905 sq ft

Introducing 577 W Cloverhurst Avenue, a remarkable transformation of a small cottage into a sprawling 6,000 square foot estate designed to captivate discerning buyers. This property showcases ingenious expansion that harmoniously integrates with its surroundings, perfectly situated on an expansive lot. Nestled on one of Fivepoints premier streets, this home boasts breathtaking curb appeal that commands attention from the moment you arrive. Impeccable custom landscaping frames the entrance, setting the stage for what lies within—a residence that exudes magazine-worthy allure. Enter through the welcoming foyer, where two spacious sitting rooms on the left overlook the manicured front lawn, ideal for morning coffee or hosting gatherings with friends. To the right, a grand formal dining room awaits, perfect for elegant dinners and special occasions. Continuing through the central foyer, you'll find a strategically placed full bathroom before entering the gourmet kitchen. This culinary haven blends modern luxury with ample space, featuring top-tier appliances, expansive countertops, and distinctive exposed brick accents that add character and charm. Adjacent to the kitchen, the great room beckons with its expansive layout, multiple sitting areas, elegant coffered ceilings, and a cozy fireplace. A convenient wet bar enhances its appeal as a space for relaxation and entertaining. Flowing seamlessly from the great room is a spacious screened porch, distinguished by vaulted wood ceilings and an additional stone fireplace. Equipped with multiple porch heaters, this inviting space ensures year-round comfort and offers serene views of the dreamy backyard—an oasis ideal for unwinding and entertaining. Down the hall, a guest bedroom with an en-suite bathroom provides convenience and privacy, complementing the home's thoughtful layout. As you continue through the home, The master suite awaits and is a luxurious retreat fit for royalty, featuring gleaming hardwood floors and a private exit to the back porch, adding exclusivity and ease of access. The newly renovated master bathroom, crafted by Athens' most meticulous contractors, boasts quartz countertops, a double vanity, a spa-like tiled shower with multiple heads, and heated floors for year-round comfort—a testament to luxury and craftsmanship. The first floor is enriched by a versatile flex room that offers flexibility as an additional bedroom or entertainment area. Adjacent to this space is a convenient half bathroom, making it effortless to convert to a full bathroom if desired. Adding to its appeal, this area features its own exit leading to the enchanting backyard, enhancing both accessibility and charm. Upstairs, thoughtful design continues with a substantial bedroom offering its own ensuite bathroom, along with another sizable bedroom down the hall, also with ensuite facilities. Ample closet space and strategic separation ensure privacy and comfort, catering perfectly to guests. Completing this exceptional residence is the enchanting backyard, a haven of custom landscaping, astro turf resembling manicured grass, and meticulously laid stone patio areas ideal for relaxing evenings. A stunning stone wall terraces the yard, originally part of the Cloverhurst Country Club, featuring a fireplace nestled within—a true outdoor retreat blending beauty and functionality. Secure your exclusive tour today to experience firsthand the unparalleled charm and allure of this truly unique property, ensuring you don't miss out on this exceptional opportunity.

Built in 1960
View Details
Listing #CL349702
Property at 357 Peter Street
Residential
$2,500,000 $1602.56/sq ft

357 Peter Street

Athens, GA 30601

5 bed
2.0 bath
1,560 sq ft

Unparalleled development opportunity in the heart of Athens, this 1.96-acre parcel features 480+ feet of frontage along the Firefly Trail. Zoned RM-1 (16 beds/acre), this site is the ideal canvas for luxury townhomes or condos. Located across the street from the Peter Street entrance and iconic reconstructed trestle bridge, the property offers ultimate walkability. It is situated just steps away from the North Oconee River, Greenway Trail, Dudley Park, Downtown, and Trail Creek Park. Future residents connect directly to UGA and Sandy Creek Nature Center via the trail network. Situated next to Mama’s Boy restaurant and near Cafe Racer, this is a rare chance for a developer to place their mark on the future of the Firefly Trail.

Built in 1920
View Details
Listing #CL345129
Property at 2880 Spartan Estates Drive
Residential
$2,498,000 $292.99/sq ft

2880 Spartan Estates Drive

Athens, GA 30606

5 bed
7.0 bath
8,526 sq ft

Beautiful Home, meticulously maintained, on beautiful acreage. Relaxing front porch has double glass and iron doors that open into a fabulous floorplan. Comfortable Office/TV Room with french doors is just off the Foyer. Another Flex Room/Dining Room/Sitting Room flanks the other side of the Foyer. Spacious two story Great Room includes built-in bookcases and fireplace, and loads of windows that overlook private backyard. Great Room is also open to large Kitchen with oversized island, breakfast bar, lots of cabinet space, walk-in pantry, and top-of-the-line appliances including two Viking dishwashers, Viking refrigerator and freezer, vegetable sink, and Ive oven and range with custom-crafted copper vent hood. Kitchen has an open dining space and french doors that lead to a relaxing screened porch - great for outside TV watching. Oversized utility/laundry room with laundry chute from upstairs. Mud Room with built-ins. Beautifully appointed powder room. Private main level Owners Suite has a wall of windows in the sitting area that look out to large, private backyard. Luxurious Owners Bathroom has beautiful spa-like shower with double shower heads, soaking tub, spacious double vanities, his & her water closets, and custom-designed walk-in owners closet. Upper level features a fabulous open loft area and three amazing bedroom suites - each with private bathroom and walk-in closet with built-ins, as well as a spacious upstairs Media Room. Finished terrace level is an entertainers dream and features a family room with french doors out to covered back patio, game area, full kitchen with large island, full pool bathroom with steam shower, exercise/music room, large theater room, a full bedroom suite with its own private bathroom, and ...a spectacular indoor basketball court. Basketball court could be used as an exercise room or dance space. Outdoors offers spacious covered areas for seating as well as a covered grilling station with seating, a magnificent salt-water pool, enormous yard, and beautiful hardwoods. Three car garage. cul-de-sac street. 5 minutes away from Athens Academy

Built in 2023
View Details
Listing #CL350380
Property at 1355 Allgood Road
Residential
$2,375,000 $357.20/sq ft

1355 Allgood Road

Athens, GA 30606

5 bed
5.5 bath
6,649 sq ft

Custom-built in 2018, this estate perfectly balances tranquility and privacy with convenient access to Athens, the University of Georgia, downtown Watkinsville and Oconee County. The main level of the home features a spacious primary suite with vaulted ceilings and a private fireplace. The layout is ideal for both daily living and entertaining, offering an open-concept kitchen boasting custom cabinetry by Webber Coleman Woodworks, a functional laundry facility, and two guest bedrooms joined by a Jack and Jill bathroom. The upper level provides additional flexibility with a large bonus room and a full bathroom. Throughout the main level, enjoy beautiful true hardwood floors that are made of 100+ year old trees harvested from Sea Island, Georgia. The lower level has been recently updated with new flooring and includes two additional bedrooms and two bathrooms! This level opens directly to a private outdoor oasis, complete with a swimming pool, spa, outdoor kitchen, and a fireplace. With ample space throughout, this property is perfectly suited for hosting and comfort. Schedule your showing today!

Built in 2018
View Details
Listing #CL348893
Property at 1350 Allgood Road
Residential
$2,250,000 $308.22/sq ft

1350 Allgood Road

Athens, GA 30606

6 bed
4.5 bath
7,300 sq ft

Welcome to 1350 Allgood Road, where an extraordinary transformation is underway and luxury living is being redefined. Set on 5 private acres in Athens, Georgia — and zoned for the award-winning Oconee County School System — this soon-to-be masterpiece will offer an impressive 7,300 finished square feet featuring 6 bedrooms and 4.5 bathrooms designed with both elegance and functionality in mind. Every detail of this home is being thoughtfully curated with high-end finishes and timeless design. From the moment you enter through the grand double front doors, you’ll immediately feel the scale and craftsmanship that set this property apart. Expect rich hardwood flooring, complemented by reclaimed brick accents in select spaces, creating a warm yet sophisticated character throughout. The trim package will be nothing short of exceptional, while the owner’s suite is being designed as a true retreat — luxurious, private, and fit for royalty. The kitchen will anchor the home with Thermador appliances, including a beautifully integrated stained wood refrigerator, blending cutting-edge performance with elevated style. As construction progresses, this home will continue to reveal its brilliance — and the finished product promises to be nothing short of breathtaking. Now is the time to walk the property, experience the setting, and watch the vision come to life. Opportunities like this are rare, and this transformation is poised to deliver a home that will absolutely blow you away.

Built in 1997
View Details
Listing #CL348610
$300K+
Average Home Price
Premium neighborhood pricing
98
Walk Score
Walker's Paradise
15%
Annual Appreciation
Strong investment potential

Why Choose Five Points?

Cultural Hub

Art galleries, live music venues, and creative spaces

Walkable Lifestyle

Everything within walking distance - shops, cafes, restaurants

Historic Character

1920s-1940s homes with original architectural details

Investment Potential

Strong appreciation rates and rental demand

Central Location

Minutes from UGA campus and downtown Athens

Community Events

Regular festivals, art walks, and neighborhood gatherings

Five Points Qualifying Area Map

View the 2-mile radius from Five Points intersection. Only properties within this area qualify. Click the red marker to see the exact intersection location, and the property marker for details.

Loading Five Points Properties Map...

9
Qualifying Property
0.5mi
Average Walk to Downtown
98
Walk Score Rating

Ready to Buy in Five Points?

Contact Hamilton Agency to explore Five Points homes for sale and secure your place in Athens' most walkable, culturally rich neighborhood.

Walk to Athens' Best

World-class dining, shopping, and culture at your doorstep

Exceptional Dining

Five & Ten

Athens' premier upscale restaurant featuring innovative Southern cuisine and an award-winning wine program. A culinary destination that puts Five Points on the map.

Visit Website →

Donna Chang's

Upscale Chinese cuisine with modern presentation and authentic flavors. This stylish restaurant brings sophisticated Asian dining to the heart of Five Points.

Visit Website →

El Barrio

Vibrant Latin American restaurant and bar with creative cocktails, fresh ceviches, and lively atmosphere. Perfect for dinner dates and social gatherings.

Visit Website →

Marker 7 Coastal Grill

Fresh seafood and coastal cuisine in a relaxed setting. Known for their raw bar, fish tacos, and oceanside vibes in the heart of Georgia.

Visit Website →

Independent Baking Co.

Artisan bakery and cafe serving fresh-baked breads, pastries, and coffee. A neighborhood staple for morning routines and casual meetings.

Visit Website →

The Cafe on Lumpkin

Cozy neighborhood cafe perfect for working remotely, casual dining, and community connections. Local favorite for coffee and comfort food.

Local Favorite

Unique Shopping

Avid Bookshop

Independent bookstore featuring carefully curated selections, local authors, and community events. A literary hub that embodies Five Points' intellectual culture.

Visit Website →

Masada Leather and Gifts

Handcrafted leather goods, unique gifts, and artisan accessories. This local treasure offers items you won't find anywhere else.

Local Artisan Shop

Appointments at Five

Antiques, vintage finds, and collectibles in a charming setting. Perfect for discovering unique pieces to decorate your new Five Points home.

Antiques & Gifts

Amelia's Apparel

Boutique clothing and accessories with a focus on unique styles and quality pieces. Local fashion destination for distinctive wardrobe finds.

Boutique Fashion

ADD Drug Store

Historic neighborhood pharmacy and soda fountain serving classic milkshakes, sodas, and comfort food. A true piece of Athens history.

Historic Soda Fountain

Social Scene

Five Points Bottle Shop

Curated wine and beer selection with knowledgeable staff and regular tastings. The perfect spot to discover new favorites and stock your home bar.

Wine & Beer Shop

5 Point Growlers

Craft beer growler station and bottle shop featuring local and regional breweries. Great selection for beer enthusiasts and casual drinkers alike.

Craft Beer Specialist

The Root

Neighborhood bar with a relaxed atmosphere, good drinks, and friendly locals. The kind of place where you'll become a regular and feel part of the community.

Neighborhood Bar
Five Points Athens community events and local gathering spaces

Strong Community Spirit

Walkable Streets

Tree-lined sidewalks and pedestrian-friendly intersections make walking a pleasure

Community Events

Regular street festivals, art walks, and neighborhood gatherings

Local Character

Preserved historic architecture mixed with thoughtful modern development

Pet-Friendly

Many properties welcome pets, and the neighborhood is very dog-friendly

Getting Around Five Points

Walkable

Most errands can be accomplished on foot. High walk score neighborhood.

Bike-Friendly

Safe cycling routes to downtown, campus, and other neighborhoods.

Central Location

Quick access to UGA campus, downtown Athens, and major highways.

Five Points Market Insights

Investment opportunity in Athens' most walkable neighborhood

Home Values

Cottages (2BR) $350K-$500K
Updated Homes (3BR) $450K-$650K
Investment Properties $400K-$750K

Investment Benefits

  • 15% Annual Appreciation
  • Strong Rental Demand
  • Historic Preservation
  • Walk Score 98

Own Your Place in Five Points

Make Athens' cultural heart your home. Discover available Five Points properties and invest in a neighborhood where historic character meets modern convenience.